In short

On the label, look at who produced it, where the olives come from, the harvest year and the words "cold extraction". Then smell it and taste it. A good extra virgin smells of grass, leaf or artichoke, leaves a little bitterness on the tongue and stings the throat. If it tastes of nothing or tastes rancid, leave it.

To be extra virgin, an oil must have an acidity of no more than 0.8% and no defects when tasted. That is the minimum. Between an oil that only just passes and one that is well made there is a big difference, and you can spot it with these seven checks.

1. Who made it and where the olives come from

If the label says "blend of olive oils of European Union origin", or "not of European Union origin", the oil comes from more than one country and you don't know who made it. Look for the name of the farm and the place where the olive trees grow.

2. The harvest year

The "best before" date is set by whoever packs the oil, and it doesn't say when the olives were picked. The harvest year, on the other hand, can only be printed if all the oil comes from that harvest. The season runs from October to September, so oil harvested this autumn belongs to the 2026/2027 season.

3. "Cold extraction" has a precise meaning

It means the olives were worked below 27 °C. Phrases like "processed at gentle temperatures" are not provided for by law and don't tell you how warm the olives were when they were worked. We explain the two wordings that are allowed in the article on cold pressing.

4. A good extra virgin isn't very cheap

One litre of oil takes roughly 6 to 10 kilos of olives, depending on the variety and the year. On top of that come the picking, the mill and the container. An Italian extra virgin at a few euros a litre has cut corners somewhere.

5. Smell it

Warm a little oil in a glass by holding it in your hands, then smell it. A good oil reminds you of cut grass, leaf, artichoke, almond or apple. If it smells of nothing, it has lost its aroma. If it smells of wet cardboard, mould or overripe olives, it has a defect.

6. If it stings your throat, that's a good sign

Many people think an oil that stings has gone off. It is the other way round. Bitterness and pepperiness come from the polyphenols, and on the official tasters' sheet they are listed among the oil's good qualities.

7. Ask the person selling it

Someone who produces oil can tell you where the olive trees are, when they picked and at which mill they had the olives pressed. If they can't answer, they probably bought the oil from someone else.

Three common misconceptions

  • The greener it is, the better. The colour depends on the olives and on when they were picked, and tells you nothing about quality.
  • If it thickens in the fridge, it's pure. Every oil thickens differently in the cold, and the fridge test doesn't tell you whether it is extra virgin.
  • Extra virgin isn't good for frying. It handles home frying without any trouble. Many people use other oils only because they cost less.

The surest test is tasting it

We send you 200 ml of our oil to taste at home and you only pay for shipping, which is free in and around Vasto. If you like it, the tins and their prices are in the catalogue.